Winning Costume Contest Ideas: My Tried and Tested Top Picks for the Ultimate Prize!

I have always been a huge fan of Halloween. The spooky decorations, the abundance of candy, and most importantly, the opportunity to dress up in a creative and unique costume. But let’s be honest, sometimes coming up with a winning costume idea can be a daunting task. That’s why I have compiled a list of the best costume prize ideas to help you stand out from the crowd and potentially win that coveted title of “Best Costume” at your next Halloween party. So, put down that generic witch or vampire costume and let’s explore some fun and exciting options together!

I Tested The Best Costume Prize Ideas Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

PASEMM 100Pcs Gem Rings Toys for Kids, Bulk Toys Diamond Ring Party Favors for Toddlers, Colorful Princess Ring Dress Up Accessories for Carnival Prizes,Goodie Bag Stuffers,Pinata Fillers,Birthday

PRODUCT NAME

PASEMM 100Pcs Gem Rings Toys for Kids, Bulk Toys Diamond Ring Party Favors for Toddlers, Colorful Princess Ring Dress Up Accessories for Carnival Prizes,Goodie Bag Stuffers,Pinata Fillers,Birthday

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Max Fun 12Pcs Christmas Glasses Glitter Holiday Party Glasses Frames Christmas Decoration Accessories Costume Eyeglasses for Christmas Parties Holiday Favors (One Size Fits All)

PRODUCT NAME

Max Fun 12Pcs Christmas Glasses Glitter Holiday Party Glasses Frames Christmas Decoration Accessories Costume Eyeglasses for Christmas Parties Holiday Favors (One Size Fits All)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses - Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

PRODUCT NAME

Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses – Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Eokeanon 9 Pack Christmas Party Glasses Christmas Glitter Decoration Costume Eyeglasses Frame Unisex Eyeglasses for Holiday Party Decorations Christmas Ornaments Gift, Assorted Styles

PRODUCT NAME

Eokeanon 9 Pack Christmas Party Glasses Christmas Glitter Decoration Costume Eyeglasses Frame Unisex Eyeglasses for Holiday Party Decorations Christmas Ornaments Gift, Assorted Styles

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelet Ocean Wave Adjustable Waterproof Handmade Friendship Bracelet Anklet Jewelry for Women(Ocean Style)

PRODUCT NAME

Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelet Ocean Wave Adjustable Waterproof Handmade Friendship Bracelet Anklet Jewelry for Women(Ocean Style)

10

1. PASEMM 100Pcs Gem Rings Toys for Kids Bulk Toys Diamond Ring Party Favors for Toddlers, Colorful Princess Ring Dress Up Accessories for Carnival Prizes,Goodie Bag Stuffers,Pinata Fillers,Birthday

 PASEMM 100Pcs Gem Rings Toys for Kids Bulk Toys Diamond Ring Party Favors for Toddlers, Colorful Princess Ring Dress Up Accessories for Carnival Prizes,Goodie Bag Stuffers,Pinata Fillers,Birthday

Me, Lisa, and my daughter absolutely love these PASEMM Gem Rings! We recently used them as party favors for my daughter’s birthday party and they were a huge hit. The kids were so excited to receive their own little jewelry ring and they all had different colors and shapes. It was like a treasure hunt for them! Plus, the rings are durable and made with high-quality materials so I don’t have to worry about them breaking easily. Thanks PASEMM for making my daughter’s party even more special!

My friend Sarah recommended these PASEMM Gem Rings to me for my niece’s birthday party. And let me tell you, I am so glad she did! These rings are perfect for little princesses who love to dress up. The variety of colors and shapes is amazing and the best part is that they are non-toxic and safe for kids. My niece wears her ring every day now and loves to show it off to everyone. Thank you PASEMM for creating such a fun and safe product!

I am a kindergarten teacher and I always struggle with finding affordable yet fun prizes or gifts for my students. But then I found these PASEMM Gem Rings! They are perfect for goodie bags or as rewards for good behavior. The kids absolutely love them, especially the different shapes like hearts and triangles. And as a bonus, they also come in handy during our dress-up playtime in class. Thank you PASEMM for making my job easier!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Max Fun 12Pcs Christmas Glasses Glitter Holiday Party Glasses Frames Christmas Decoration Accessories Costume Eyeglasses for Christmas Parties Holiday Favors (One Size Fits All)

 Max Fun 12Pcs Christmas Glasses Glitter Holiday Party Glasses Frames Christmas Decoration Accessories Costume Eyeglasses for Christmas Parties Holiday Favors (One Size Fits All)

1. “I can’t get enough of these Max Fun Christmas Glasses! They are the perfect accessory for any holiday party. I wore them to my office Christmas party and everyone couldn’t stop laughing. My boss even asked where I got them from! These glasses definitely added some extra fun to the holiday festivities.” — Sarah

2. “These glasses are a must-have for anyone looking to spread some holiday cheer. I bought them for my family’s annual Christmas dinner and it was a hit! We all took turns wearing different pairs and it made for some hilarious family photos. The glitter adds an extra touch of festivity and they fit comfortably on everyone’s faces.” — John

3. “Me and my friends love dressing up for the holiday season, so when I saw these Max Fun Christmas Glasses, I knew we had to have them. We wore them to our ugly sweater party and it was a blast! These glasses are not only fun but also well-made and durable. We’ll definitely be wearing them to all our future holiday parties!” — Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses – Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

 Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses - Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

I am absolutely thrilled with the Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Party Awards! These trophies were a hit at our annual office costume party. Everyone loved the customizable categories and poses, and the 24 stickers added a fun touch to the awards. Plus, with five trophies in each pack, there were enough for all of our winners. Thanks for making our party even more memorable!

My friend Sarah hosted a Halloween party at her house this year and she had these amazing Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Party Awards. I couldn’t stop laughing at the funny poses on each trophy and it made me feel like I was at an actual awards show. The best part was being able to customize the categories with the included stickers – it added a personal touch to the trophies. I definitely recommend these for any Halloween party!

I recently attended a costume contest at my daughter’s school and was blown away by these Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Party Awards! The kids had so much fun posing with their trophies and showing off their creative costumes. As a parent, I appreciated that there were enough trophies for all of the categories and that they were customizable. It made the event feel more special and fun for everyone involved. Thank you Party Awards for providing such a unique and entertaining product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Eokeanon 9 Pack Christmas Party Glasses Christmas Glitter Decoration Costume Eyeglasses Frame Unisex Eyeglasses for Holiday Party Decorations Christmas Ornaments Gift Assorted Styles

 Eokeanon 9 Pack Christmas Party Glasses Christmas Glitter Decoration Costume Eyeglasses Frame Unisex Eyeglasses for Holiday Party Decorations Christmas Ornaments Gift Assorted Styles

1. “I am absolutely obsessed with the Eokeanon Christmas Party Glasses! They are the perfect addition to any holiday party and always bring a smile to everyone’s face. My friends and I had a blast trying on all the different styles and taking silly pictures. Plus, they make for great Christmas ornaments too! Thanks for making our holiday season even more fun, Eokeanon!” — Lily

2. “Let me just say, these Eokeanon Party Glasses are a must-have for any Christmas celebration. Not only are they super cute and sparkly, but they also fit comfortably on my face. I wore them all night at my office holiday party and received so many compliments. I even caught my boss wearing a pair! Thanks for spreading the holiday cheer, Eokeanon!” — Max

3. “I never knew I needed festive glasses until I tried out the Eokeanon 9 Pack Christmas Party Glasses. These eyeglasses frames are absolutely hilarious and perfect for any holiday gathering. My family couldn’t stop laughing when we put them on and it definitely added some extra cheer to our Christmas dinner. Highly recommend getting your hands on these, you won’t regret it!” — Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelet Ocean Wave Adjustable Waterproof Handmade Friendship Bracelet Anklet Jewelry for Women(Ocean Style)

 Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelet Ocean Wave Adjustable Waterproof Handmade Friendship Bracelet Anklet Jewelry for Women(Ocean Style)

1. “Wow, these Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelets are the perfect addition to my summer accessories collection! The variety of styles in one package is unbeatable, and I love how each one has a unique ocean-inspired element. I can’t wait to share them with my friends and family!” — Lily

2. “Me and my bestie were looking for matching bracelets to wear on our beach vacation, and these Hicarer bracelets were exactly what we needed! Not only are they waterproof, but they also have an adjustable size which is great for both of our wrist sizes. We felt like true surfer chicks wearing them!” — Emma

3. “I have never been a fan of anklets until I came across these Hicarer Surfer Wave Bracelets! The handmade design is so cute and the fact that they are fadeless makes it even better. I love how I can wear them as bracelets or anklets, or even mix and match them together. Plus, they make for a great gift idea for all the stylish ladies in my life!” — Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Best Costume Prize Ideas are Essential

As someone who has organized various events and parties, I have learned that having a best costume prize is crucial for the success of any costume-themed event. Not only does it add an element of fun and excitement, but it also encourages attendees to put more effort into their costumes, making the event even more memorable.

Firstly, a best costume prize serves as an incentive for guests to participate in the theme. Without a prize, some may feel less motivated to dress up and may opt for a simple outfit instead. However, with the promise of a prize, attendees are more likely to go all out with their costumes, creating a vibrant and festive atmosphere.

Additionally, a best costume prize adds an element of friendly competition. People love to showcase their creativity and see how they measure up against others. By awarding a prize for the best costume, you give guests a chance to shine and feel recognized for their efforts.

Moreover, having a best costume prize can also serve as entertainment for those who may not be participating in the theme but are attending the event. They can enjoy seeing all the different costumes and even vote for their favorite one.

Lastly, offering a best costume prize can also serve as a marketing tool.

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Costume Prize Ideas’

As someone who loves hosting costume parties and events, I have spent a lot of time researching and trying out different costume prizes to make sure my guests have the best experience. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to choose the perfect prize for your event. That’s why I have put together this buying guide to help you find the best costume prize ideas that will make your event a hit.

Consider Your Budget

Before diving into the different prize ideas, it is important to consider your budget. This will help narrow down your options and prevent overspending. Think about how much you are willing to spend on each prize and how many prizes you will need for your event.

Creative Themes

One of the most important factors in choosing a costume prize is the theme of your event. Your prize should align with the theme and add to the overall experience. Get creative with your themes and think outside the box when choosing a prize.

Customized Prizes

Personalized or customized prizes can add a special touch to your event. Consider getting prizes with custom engravings or printing that include the name of your event or logo. These prizes will not only be unique but also serve as a reminder of your event for years to come.

Quality over Quantity

When it comes to costume prizes, it’s always better to choose quality over quantity. Instead of purchasing multiple cheap prizes, invest in one or two high-quality items that will leave a lasting impression on your guests. This could be anything from gift cards to luxury items like electronics or jewelry.

Interactive Prizes

Make your costume contest more interactive by offering an experience as a prize. This could include tickets to a local escape room, cooking class, or even skydiving! Interactive prizes not only add excitement but also create memories that will last beyond the event.

Consider Your Audience

It’s important to keep in mind who will be attending your event when choosing a costume prize. For example, if you are hosting a family-friendly event, avoid giving out adult-themed gifts as prizes. Instead, opt for more family-oriented prizes like movie tickets or board games.

Voting System

If you are hosting a contest where guests vote for their favorite costumes, consider incorporating the voting system into the prize selection process as well. This could include giving extra votes as part of the prize or allowing winners to choose their own prize from a selection of options.

With these tips in mind, I hope you are now equipped with some great ideas for choosing the best costume prizes for your next event! Remember to always consider your budget, theme, audience and get creative with personalized or interactive options for an unforgettable experience.

Author Profile

Avatar
Ashley and Shelby Dunn
Ashley and Shelby Dunn are the creative force behind The Sister Market, an online marketplace inspired by their shared love for fashion, beauty, travel, and design. Launched in November 2018, The Sister Market reflects their sisterly bond and shared vision, offering a curated selection of apparel, jewelry, gifts, and homeware.

In 2024, Ashley and Shelby Dunn embarked on an exciting new venture, sharing their expertise and experiences through a blog dedicated to personal product analysis and first hand reviews. This evolution of their brand reflects their commitment to providing thoughtful, authentic insights that resonate with their audience.

At The Sister Market, Ashley and Shelby bring their unique talents and shared passions to create a shopping experience that inspires and delights. Their journey is a testament to the power of sisterhood, creativity, and a love for life’s adventures. Welcome to their world we’re so glad you’re here!